 |
 |
 |
 |
| |
|
Worker rotation is an administrative control that involves moving workers to different jobs periodically within a shift. On any given worksite, there are certain tasks that are more stressful and require more energy than others. Often, these are the tasks that lead to overuse injuries. The extra stress could be associated with repetition, overhead or stooped posture, or excessive amount of force necessary to complete the task. Worker rotation differs from other engineering controls in which the working environment or tools are altered. Worker rotation does not change how the work is done, but spreads the workload of the task to many workers, instead of only a select few.
Worker rotation works best when the jobs are distinctly different in terms of risk factors. For the best recovery of fatigue, jobs that require extra exertion should be alternated with less demanding jobs. An example of inappropriate worker rotation is alternating drilling overhead with lifting heavy cement bags; both tasks are physically demanding. However, alternating drilling overhead with low-intensity worksite clean-up would be appropriate. Similarly, workers should use different muscle groups in consecutive tasks. For example, workers could rotate between lifting tasks using low back muscles and use of power hand tools.
The first step towards implementation is designing the rotation schedule. First, the most stressful tasks should be identified. Next, the time it takes to cause fatigue performing these tasks should be determined. The length of time at each task station should be based on the most demanding task. Adequate rest periods should still be given when using a worker rotation.
A poorly designed worker rotation can actually increase worker stress levels. Worker rotation is not appropriate in the following situations:
- Tasks with extremely high risk of injury. The risk should be protected from the entire workforce. Training a select group to complete high risk tasks safely is a better alternative.
- Jobs/tasks that are extremely fatiguing for certain muscle groups should not be in included in a worker rotation, especially when followed by other tasks using the same muscle groups. Engineering controls and worker education on energy saving techniques are better alternatives.
Worker rotation is appropriate in the following situations:
- Tasks that cause fatigue after performing them for two or more hours.
- Tasks performed in fatiguing conditions (ie. extreme heat, humidity, or cold).
- Shifts longer than eight hours.
- Visually and attention demanding tasks, such as inspection.
|
|
| |
Musculoskeletal disorders associated with:
- Overhead work
- Stooped postures
- Manual materials handling
- Stressful hand and wrist activity
- Kneeling & squatting
- Repetitive work
|
|
| |
People participating in a worker rotation are still exposed to risk factors that could cause injuries. However, the length of exposure to the risk is decreased. For example, workers do not have to sustain awkward postures or be exposed to repetitive work for long periods of time.
Quality of Evidence
- Independent published studies have found a risk reduction.
- Manufacturers, vendors, or worksites have reported a risk reduction.
- Safety and health experts believe there is a risk reduction.
Independent published studies report that there is a decrease in the risk of developing injury when a worker is exposed to a variety of tasks requiring different muscle groups and exertion levels. Studies also have shown that workers who perform repeated activities above shoulder level are at greater risk of sustaining shoulder musculoskeletal disorders. Workers who spend more time in stooped posture or other awkward back postures are at a higher risk for developing low back problems. Worker rotation is an effective intervention for reducing this time.
It should be remembered that worker rotation does not change the risk factors of a given task. The risk factors are distributed over more workers, but the risk of injury is still present.
|
|
| |
Productivity is maintained or increased on a worksite with an effective worker rotation.
Quality of Evidence
- Independent published studies have found an increase in productivity.
- Manufacturers or vendors have reported an increase in productivity.
- Safety and health experts believe there is an increase in productivity.
An independent published study reports an increase of productivity when worker rotations are used. Due to decreased fatigue, boredom, and absenteeism, workers are motivated to perform better. When workers are rotated to different tasks, the work force becomes multi-skilled. There is more flexibility on worksites when faced with illnesses or workers taking vacation time.
Worksites report that workers are more satisfied with job assignment when using worker rotation. There is a perceived fairness when workers are required to do tasks considered to be ‘good’ and ‘bad’ jobs.
Worker rotations have also been shown to decrease productivity. If workers are rotated to jobs in which they are unfamiliar, their productivity decreases. Sufficient training of new tasks eliminates this possibility, but is often overlooked when implementing a worker rotation.
|
|
| |
No specific calculation ROI information exists for this particular solution, however, there are some general approaches that might be useful for a “Return On Investment” analysis. For a general discussion of these approaches, visit our “Return on Investment Calculation” page. |
|
| |
Guidelines for designing worker rotations can be found at:
|
|
| |
Worker rotation can be effectively used for workers placed on light duty after returning from an injury. If a worker has limitations, the tasks they perform within the worker rotation can be altered.
Although worker rotation can be an effective intervention, implementation of engineering controls is usually a better solution for decreasing the risk of MSDs. |
|
 |
|
- General Labor
- Clear, prepare and fence construction sites
- Concrete and asphalt paving & patching
- Construct and remove concrete forms (sidewalks)
- Dig trenches, shovel and level ground
- Erect and disassemble scaffolding, shoring, braces temporary structures
- Housekeeping and debris removal or recycling
- Install traffic control markers, barricades and maintain traffic patterns
- Landscaping
- Load, unload and distribute construction materials
- Manual demolition
- Position and join sewer, water and storm drains
- Remove hazardous materials
- Tend concrete mixers, pumps and fire proofing sprayers
- Tend pavement cutters and concrete grinders
- Use jackhammers and earth tampers
- Interiors, Drywall & Glass
- Cut and install metal framing for windows and atriums
- Cut, etch and install decorative glass
- Cut, place and install windows, mirrors and protective glass and plastic
- Frame walls using wood studs, metal studs and door bucks
- Install and finish wood flooring
- Install cabinets, countertops, molding and doors
- Install floor coverings, carpet and tile
- Install partitions or cubicles
- Install suspended ceiling systems
- Install terrazzo and polished concrete
- Move and install drywall or panels
- Place and install fixtures and hardware
- Tape, mud and sand drywall
- Use ladders, scaffolds and lifts
- Masonry, Cement & Plaster
- Applying coats of plaster or stucco
- Caulking, sealing and waterproofing installations
- Chipping, scraping and grinding surfaces or joints
- Cleaning and finishing installations
- Cutting bricks, blocks, stone, concrete, tile or terrazzo
- Drilling holes and installing reinforcing rods and anchors
- Erecting and dismantling scaffolding
- Forming, pouring, laying or applying refractory materials
- Laying or setting brick, block, stone, tile or marble
- Mixing cement, mortar, plaster, or grout
- Operating power vibrator to compact concrete or grout
- Pouring or transporting cement, mortar, plaster, or grout
- Spreading, leveling, and smoothing concrete, mortar or terrazzo mixtures
- Transporting bricks, blocks, stone, tile, terrazzo or marble and riggings
- Reinforced Concrete
- Build forms, lay down decking
- Chipping & surface preparation
- Cut or bend rebar
- Finish concrete
- Mixing concrete
- Pour, pump, vibrate concrete
- Remove forms
- Surface grinding or cutting
- Tie or cap rebar
- Unload, store, move, place rebar
- Sheet Metal & HVAC
- Apply caulk, cement and mastic sealants
- Assemble fittings and fasten seams and joints using hand and power tools
- Clean, remove and repair existing ductwork/HVAC
- Install flashing, rain gutters and down spouts
- Install heating and air conditioning duct hangers & ductwork
- Install risers
- Layout, shear, drill and punch holes in metal
- Operate laser cutter and metal shearing machine
- Operate metal press, hand brake and forming machines
- Rig and set HVAC equipment with cranes, helicopters, hoists and lifts
- Shape metal material over anvils, blocks or other forms
- Trim, file, grind, deburr, buff and smooth assembled parts
- Unload and stock metal sheets and coils
- Weld, braze and solder seams and joints
|
 |
 |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |